How Effective Are Fad Diets Like The Cabbage Soup Diet?
In the last few years, there have been many "extreme" or "fad" diets. Some have the dieter eating little to no protein, or no fats at all, or almost no carbs. One of these is the Cabbage Soup Diet, or Sacred Heart Diet. Another spinoff of this is the TJ Miracle Soup Diet.
What, exactly, is the Cabbage Soup Diet? Well, Wikipedia gives it to you in a nutshell:
"The Cabbage soup diet is a radical weight loss diet designed around heavy consumption of a low-calorie cabbage soup over the time of seven days. It is generally considered a fad diet, in that it is designed for short-term weight-loss and requires no long-term commitment. It has inspired several copy-cats based around similar principles.
"The typical claimed intent of the diet is to lose 10 pounds (4.5 kg) of weight in a week, though nutritional experts point out that it is nearly impossible to lose that much fat within a week. This has lent credence to claims that much of the weight lost is water.
"On some original documents mentioning the diet, it was claimed the diet is designed for obese heart-surgery patients, so they could lose weight quickly and therefore be at lower risk of complications during surgery. However, these claims remain unverified."
It's just like that with most "extreme" or fad diets. The dieter often must cut out whole categories of foods for days at a time, such as proteins on the original cabbage soup diet.
For example, on Day 4 of that diet, the dieter can eat as much of the soup as he wants - and the remainder of that day's food allowance is "up to eight bananas and as much skimmed milk as you like." Wikipedia also outlines the recipe for the cabbage soup itself, which is mainly cabbage, canned tomatoes, and herbs.
How can this kind of diet be healthy? That's just not enough protein, and there's a lot of sodium there as well. Human bodies need proteins, and we need carbs, as well as sufficient intake from every food group, every day. Most Americans need to reduce their sodium intake as well.
Cutting out essential nutrients makes the body drain water and go into a "hoarding" mode. This is when the body's metabolism tries to save itself from starvation, so it slows down drastically in order to use less calories. Another problem is that cutting out most of the protein from a person's diet can cause the body to start metabolizing its own lean muscle mass.
Is this what the dieter wants? No, of course not. Someone trying to lose weight wants to keep the metabolism running at a high rate, reduce fat, and increase their lean muscle mass. And for long-term health, human bodies need to maintain a healthy, varied diet as well.
Someone who is very overweight or obese, or a new mother wanting to reduce her postpartum belly fat, can easily be tempted to use a fad diet because of the promise of quick results. The best idea, however, is to focus on long-term vitality, and fad diets don't help with that at all.
For the best results in long-term health as well as loss of fat, dieters should keep away from any fad diet as all the weight-loss pills that keep coming on the market. Dieters should replace processed foods and snacks with raw fruits and vegetables, increase water intake, and build up lean muscle mass with moderate exercise and focused weight training.
What, exactly, is the Cabbage Soup Diet? Well, Wikipedia gives it to you in a nutshell:
"The Cabbage soup diet is a radical weight loss diet designed around heavy consumption of a low-calorie cabbage soup over the time of seven days. It is generally considered a fad diet, in that it is designed for short-term weight-loss and requires no long-term commitment. It has inspired several copy-cats based around similar principles.
"The typical claimed intent of the diet is to lose 10 pounds (4.5 kg) of weight in a week, though nutritional experts point out that it is nearly impossible to lose that much fat within a week. This has lent credence to claims that much of the weight lost is water.
"On some original documents mentioning the diet, it was claimed the diet is designed for obese heart-surgery patients, so they could lose weight quickly and therefore be at lower risk of complications during surgery. However, these claims remain unverified."
It's just like that with most "extreme" or fad diets. The dieter often must cut out whole categories of foods for days at a time, such as proteins on the original cabbage soup diet.
For example, on Day 4 of that diet, the dieter can eat as much of the soup as he wants - and the remainder of that day's food allowance is "up to eight bananas and as much skimmed milk as you like." Wikipedia also outlines the recipe for the cabbage soup itself, which is mainly cabbage, canned tomatoes, and herbs.
How can this kind of diet be healthy? That's just not enough protein, and there's a lot of sodium there as well. Human bodies need proteins, and we need carbs, as well as sufficient intake from every food group, every day. Most Americans need to reduce their sodium intake as well.
Cutting out essential nutrients makes the body drain water and go into a "hoarding" mode. This is when the body's metabolism tries to save itself from starvation, so it slows down drastically in order to use less calories. Another problem is that cutting out most of the protein from a person's diet can cause the body to start metabolizing its own lean muscle mass.
Is this what the dieter wants? No, of course not. Someone trying to lose weight wants to keep the metabolism running at a high rate, reduce fat, and increase their lean muscle mass. And for long-term health, human bodies need to maintain a healthy, varied diet as well.
Someone who is very overweight or obese, or a new mother wanting to reduce her postpartum belly fat, can easily be tempted to use a fad diet because of the promise of quick results. The best idea, however, is to focus on long-term vitality, and fad diets don't help with that at all.
For the best results in long-term health as well as loss of fat, dieters should keep away from any fad diet as all the weight-loss pills that keep coming on the market. Dieters should replace processed foods and snacks with raw fruits and vegetables, increase water intake, and build up lean muscle mass with moderate exercise and focused weight training.
Source...